This flannelboard is on pages 163-164 of The Complete Book of Activities, Games, Stories, Props, Recipes, and Dances by Pamela Schiller. We keep our copy in professional reference because there is a lot of good stuff in here (really, you should interloan a copy if you don't have it). Due to copyright, I can't tell you the whole story, but here are the basics.
A girl named Linda made 5 different cookie shapes-a duck, a rabbit, a dog, a cat, and a bear. Then she decorated them fancy-with dots, stripes, swirls, x's, and plaid. (I also like the matching aspect of this story.) At the end of the story, after all of the cookies are in the cookie jar, they sneak out and dance away.
Cate is hosting this week's round-up at Storytiming. Have a great week!